top of page
Search

Drawing Districts by Arithmetic: North Carolina

5 days ago
7 min read

Martin A. Ginsburg, RN · November 12, 2026


North Carolina has enacted seven congressional maps since 2016. Five were used in elections, and two were struck down before anyone voted under them. Only one of those changes was required by the census, when North Carolina gained a 14th seat after 2020.

The rest came from lawsuits, court orders and the legislature's own decision to redraw.


Most voters never see how those lines get drawn. They see the result: a district that runs from their neighborhood to a county they have never visited, and a representative who was effectively chosen when the map was printed. This post shows what North Carolina's maps have been, and then shows a different way to draw them: by arithmetic, from a corner of the State, with no election results or party data anywhere in the process.

Seven maps in ten years

Courts have twice found that the General Assembly drew North Carolina's congressional map for partisan advantage, and the legislature said so openly in 2016 and again in 2025.

Plan

Enacted

Drawn by

Used in

What happened

SB 2

Feb. 19, 2016

General Assembly

2016, 2018

Replaced the 2011 map after a federal court struck two districts for racial gerrymandering. A State court struck SB 2 as a partisan gerrymander in October 2019.

HB 1029

Nov. 15, 2019

General Assembly

2020

Remedial map. Replaced after the 2020 census.

SB 740

Nov. 4, 2021

General Assembly

Never used

Struck by the N.C. Supreme Court as a partisan gerrymander, Feb. 4, 2022.

SB 745

Feb. 17, 2022

General Assembly

Never used

Rejected by the State trial court six days later.

Interim plan

Feb. 23, 2022

Court-appointed special masters

2022

The only map in the set not drawn by the legislature. The delegation split 7 to 7.

SB 757

Oct. 25, 2023

General Assembly

2024

Drawn after the N.C. Supreme Court reversed itself and held partisan-gerrymandering claims are not for the courts. The delegation went to 10 to 4.

SB 249

Oct. 22, 2025

General Assembly

2026

A mid-decade redraw of Districts 1 and 3, intended to add one Republican seat.

The 2016 map is the clearest record of intent. The chairman of the redistricting committee, Rep. David Lewis, told colleagues: "I think electing Republicans is better than electing Democrats. So I drew this map to help foster what I think is better for the country." He said the target was 10 Republicans and 3 Democrats because he did "not believe it [would be] possible to draw a map with 11 Republicans and 2 Democrats." The U.S. Supreme Court quoted those words in Rucho v. Common Cause (2019), then held that federal courts cannot decide partisan-gerrymandering claims.


That ruling left the question to the States. North Carolina's Supreme Court took it up in 2022, struck the legislature's map, and then reversed itself in 2023. Since then, the only check on how the lines are drawn is the legislature itself. The 2025 redraw is what that looks like: no new census, no court order, only a decision to move six coastal counties into one district and four inland counties into another.


This is not a one-party problem. Democrats controlled the General Assembly for most of the last century and drew the maps then. Their 1992 map's 12th District, which the Supreme Court described in Shaw v. Reno as winding "in snakelike fashion" along I-85, was struck on racial grounds. The issue is the pen, not who is holding it this decade.


How the arithmetic works

The method replaces judgment about voters with three fixed rules: where to start, which lines may be used, and when to stop.

1.       Start at a corner. The first district starts at the corner of the State whose angle is closest to 90 degrees. Ties go to the northernmost, then the westernmost. If no corner qualifies, it starts at the State's geographic center.

2.       Grow along two axes. From that corner, the district grows by equal distances along an X axis and a Y axis, like a square being drawn outward, until it holds its share of people.

3.       Stop at the population. North Carolina's 2020 population is 10,438,400, so each of its 14 districts must hold 745,600 people. Every district here is within one-quarter of one percent of that number, or about 1,864 people either way.

4.       Use only allowed lines. A district boundary may follow an Interstate, a U.S. highway, a State route numbered with one to three digits, a county route numbered with two to four digits, a county line, the coast or the State line. Nothing else.

5.       Start the next district at the last one's corner. Each new district begins where two drawn districts meet, or at the next corner of the State, and grows the same way into land not yet assigned.

6.       Aim for a square. Where the population can be reached more than one way, choose the shape whose length is closest to its width.

What the method never looks at matters as much as what it does. It uses no voting history, no party registration, no incumbent's address and no racial or ethnic data. The only number it reads is how many people live in each piece of land, from the 2020 Census.


Cities get no special treatment. A district line may run through a city if that is where the arithmetic puts it, the same way a county line runs through farmland. Fayetteville, Charlotte and Raleigh are each split or kept whole by the rules, not by a decision about who lives there.


What it produced

All 14 districts came in within a quarter of one percent of 745,600, and 11 of the 14 have a length-to-width ratio of 1.42 or better.

District

Where

People

From 745,600

Length : width

1

Northeast: Elizabeth City, Greenville, New Bern

745,361

−0.03%

1.04 : 1

2

Northern Wake, Rocky Mount, Vance, Granville

745,748

+0.02%

1.11 : 1

3

Raleigh, Johnston, Goldsboro

744,503

−0.15%

1.01 : 1

4

Wilmington, Jacksonville, Morehead City

744,976

−0.08%

1.22 : 1

5

Durham, Orange, Alamance

744,345

−0.17%

1.22 : 1

6

Cary, western Wake, Chatham, Lee

746,568

+0.13%

1.13 : 1

7

Fayetteville, Robeson, Moore

745,879

+0.04%

1.10 : 1

8

Greensboro, Winston-Salem, Stokes

744,337

−0.17%

1.15 : 1

9

High Point, Randolph, Davidson, Salisbury

745,923

+0.04%

2.03 : 1

10

Union, Stanly, eastern Mecklenburg

745,887

+0.04%

1.02 : 1

11

Southern and central Charlotte, eastern Gaston

744,881

−0.10%

1.42 : 1

12

Northwest, Boone to Lake Norman

746,937

+0.18%

1.02 : 1

13

Foothills, Cleveland, western Gaston

747,346

+0.23%

1.41 : 1

14

Mountains, Asheville and west

745,708

+0.01%

2.32 : 1

The two long districts are long for reasons anyone can see on a map. District 14 follows the mountains, which run southwest to northeast; once it reached the Tennessee line, the only way to add people was along the range. District 9 was held between District 8 above it and Randolph County's southern line below it, so it had to run west to reach its population.

Every boundary in the table can be described in a sentence: this highway, that county line, the coast. A voter can find their district by knowing which road they live north of.


What it does not solve yet

This is a working draft, and anyone who wants to knock it down will start with these five points, so they belong here first.

·         A person still made choices. After the first district, a person chose which corner each new district started from, and asked for some tails and notches to be pulled in. Every one of those choices is recorded, and none used party data. But a neutral rule has to settle those choices in writing before anyone sees a map, and a commission with no stake in the outcome should apply it.

·         The population standard is stricter than people think. The Constitution requires congressional districts to be equal "as nearly as is practicable." Legislatures usually draw them to within a few people. In Karcher v. Daggett (1983) the Supreme Court struck a New Jersey plan whose largest gap was 0.6984%. In Tennant v. Jefferson County Commission (2012) it upheld West Virginia's 0.79% gap because the State had neutral reasons, including not splitting counties. A quarter-percent spread is defensible only if the road-and-county rule is the stated reason for it.

·         It splits more counties. This plan divides 39 of North Carolina's 100 counties among districts. Following roads instead of county lines is what keeps the lines simple to describe, but it costs county unity. A version that keeps counties whole first and uses roads only inside them is worth drawing next.

·         The counts are close, not exact. Where a road cuts through a voting precinct, the precinct's people were divided by land area. A final plan would be counted from census blocks.

·         Neutral inputs do not promise any particular result. The method does not look at party, so it cannot promise a 7 to 7 delegation or a 10 to 4 one. Where people live decides that. Someone will run the election numbers on these districts, and they should. The point is that no one ran them while drawing.


Rules first, maps second

The difference between this map and the seven before it is the order of events. In 2016 and again in 2025, the legislature said what result it wanted and then drew lines to reach it. This method writes the rules down first, and the map is whatever the rules produce.


That order is what makes a map trustworthy. If the starting corner, the allowed lines, the population limit and the shape target are fixed in law before the census numbers arrive, then no one, of any party, can steer the result. A citizen can check the work with a road atlas and a calculator. And when the next census comes, the same rules draw the next map, without a lawsuit, a special session or a mid-decade surprise.


North Carolina has spent ten years and seven maps arguing about who should hold the pen. A better question is whether anyone should.



Sources

1.       Rucho v. Common Cause, 139 S. Ct. 2484 (2019) (Lewis statements quoted from the district court record).

2.       Shaw v. Reno, 509 U.S. 630, 635–36 (1993).

3.       Karcher v. Daggett, 462 U.S. 725 (1983). Opinion

4.       Tennant v. Jefferson Cnty. Comm'n, 567 U.S. 758 (2012) (per curiam). Opinion

5.       Loyola Law School, All About Redistricting: North Carolina (plan dates, enacting body and litigation). Link

6.       Ballotpedia, Redistricting in North Carolina ahead of the 2026 elections. Link

7.       Adam Wagner, NC Republicans release map they hope will help GOP pick up another Congressional seat, WUNC / NC Newsroom (Oct. 16, 2025). Link

8.       2024 United States House of Representatives elections in North Carolina, Wikipedia (delegation results, 2022 and 2024). Link

9.       U.S. Census Bureau, 2020 Census redistricting data by voting district, and TIGER/Line 2020 road files (population and allowed boundaries for the proposed map).


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Four Voices for Regular Order

Nov 16, 2026 · @PresRun2028 A 494-page bill and no hearing This week the Senate is moving a 494-page rewrite of the nation's permitting laws. By Professor Steve Vladeck's account, it reached the floor

 
 
 
The Reset

No more victory laps. No more payback. Last week Democrats won both houses of Congress.[1] The celebrating started before the last races were called. So did the threats: investigations from one side,

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page