top of page
Search

Four Voices for Regular Order

10 hours ago
4 min read


Nov 16, 2026 · @PresRun2028

A 494-page bill and no hearing

This week the Senate is moving a 494-page rewrite of the nation's permitting laws. By Professor Steve Vladeck's account, it reached the floor without a single hearing, markup, or committee report. It was rewritten over a weekend and attached to an unrelated House tax bill. Whatever you think of what's in it, that isn't how Congress is supposed to make law.



There's a name for the way it's supposed to work: regular order. Over the years, people in both parties and both chambers have asked Congress to get back to it. Four of them are worth hearing again.

What regular order means

Regular order is simply the normal way a bill becomes law:

  1. The bill goes to the committee that knows the subject.

  2. The committee holds public hearings, where experts and the people the bill affects get heard.

  3. Members mark it up, amending it line by line, and vote on it.

  4. The committee writes a report explaining what the bill does and why.

  5. On the floor, every member can offer amendments, and the House and Senate settle their differences.


It's slow on purpose. Each step is a chance to catch a mistake before it becomes law, and a chance for someone outside the leadership's office to be heard.

Four voices, two parties, one ask

Senator John McCain (R-Arizona), July 25, 2017. Days after his cancer diagnosis, he came back to the Senate floor and asked his colleagues to legislate the old way: "Let's trust each other. Let's return to regular order." He asked that the health committee hold hearings on health care. He also reminded the Senate what it is: "Whether or not we are of the same party, we are not the President's subordinates, we are his equal."


Representative Josh Gottheimer (D-New Jersey), 2018 and 2019. He co-chaired the Problem Solvers Caucus, which seats Democrats and Republicans in equal numbers. Its "Break the Gridlock" reforms included a regular-order rule: a bill going through the Rules Committee must get a hearing and a markup before it reaches the floor. In January 2019 the House adopted it. As Representative Gottheimer put it, the package passed "with support from both sides of the aisle, for the first time in nearly two decades."


Senator Joe Lieberman (D/I-Connecticut), December 2021. The 2000 Democratic nominee for vice president, and Senator McCain's close friend, he wrote an op-ed calling for regular order's return. He started with the basics: "'Regular order' requires that a legislative proposal be referred to the appropriate committee." And he quoted his late friend's speech.


Representative Tom Reed (R-New York), January 2019. Representative Gottheimer's Republican co-chair voted for that rules package as a show of good faith. He said the reforms would "enable rank-and-file Members to govern and make it easier for bipartisan bills to pass."


Two Republicans. Two Democrats, one of whom finished his career as an independent. Two senators and two House members. They didn't agree on much. They agreed on this.


Why both parties have a stake

Regular order isn't written in the Constitution. It lives in the rules each chamber writes for itself. But it rests on the Constitution's first working sentence: "All legislative Powers herein granted shall be vested in a Congress of the United States." In Congress, not in its leaders, and not in the White House.


That gives each party a reason of its own. If you believe in keeping strictly to the Constitution, regular order is how the legislative power stays with the members the people elected. If you believe government should represent everybody, committees are where every member's constituents get a hearing, not just the constituents of the few who write the bill behind a closed door.


Same process, two reasons, no need to agree on which one matters more.


Leaders manage. Members run it.

The Speaker of the House represents one district. Each Senate party leader represents one state. Their colleagues chose them to manage the floor, not to decide alone what the country's laws say.


It's how any well-run organization works. Managers handle the day-to-day, because the day-to-day can't wait on a committee. But the committee sets the terms the managers work within. In Congress, the committees are the members, and the members answer to us.

The promise is easy to make and hard to keep. When Paul Ryan became Speaker in October 2015, he said plainly, "The House is broken." He said the committees "should retake the lead in drafting all major legislation," and he called regular order "a matter of principle." Within weeks, the Associated Press reported that the House was under new management, but it was business as usual.


So it can't be left to the leaders. It's up to us. Ask your own representative and both your senators one question: Will you vote against a bill that skipped its hearing and its markup? If the answer is no, ask why.


Closing

Senator McCain and Senator Lieberman were close friends from opposite parties. Representatives Gottheimer and Reed co-chaired a caucus built on pairs from opposite parties. None of them asked Congress to agree. They asked it to do its work in the open, through the members, the way it was built to.


I'm an independent candidate for president. There's no paid tier and no donations: none of your money, none of your work. A free subscription lets you comment, whether to argue with me, agree, or set me straight.


Martin A. Ginsburg, RN, with Claude


Sources

  1. U.S. Const. art. I, § 1.

  2. 163 Cong. Rec. S4168–69 (daily ed. July 25, 2017) (statement of Sen. John McCain), govinfo.gov.

  3. Press Release, Rep. Josh Gottheimer, Problem Solvers Caucus Propose Changes to House Rules to "Break the Gridlock" (July 25, 2018), gottheimer.house.gov.

  4. Press Release, Rep. Josh Gottheimer, Problem Solvers Caucus Break the Gridlock Rules Reforms Pass House (Jan. 4, 2019), gottheimer.house.gov.

  5. Joe Lieberman, Bring Back "Regular Order" (Dec. 2021), reprinted by the Yale Class of 1964, yale64.org.

  6. Speaker Paul Ryan, Remarks After Election as Speaker of the House (Oct. 29, 2015), transcript at foxnews.com.

  7. Erica Werner, U.S. House Under New Management, But It's Business as Usual, Associated Press (Dec. 12, 2015), pbs.org.

  8. Steve Vladeck, 263. Congress Should Press Pause on BAAJA, One First (Nov. 16, 2026), stevevladeck.com.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
The Reset

No more victory laps. No more payback. Last week Democrats won both houses of Congress.[1] The celebrating started before the last races were called. So did the threats: investigations from one side,

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page