Coach.
I was twelve years old when someone first taught me to think.
His name was Butch. He was my football coach — put me on the offensive line and the defensive line, wherever he thought I'd do the team the most good. He was also a firefighter paramedic. Which meant that by the time I was thirteen, I could read a lethal cardiac arrhythmia on a strip. He taught me because he knew it and knowing something you could teach seemed to him like reason enough to teach it.
Butch had a way of asking questions that weren't really questions. They were traps — the good kind. The kind that snap shut on an assumption you didn't know you were making. He'd let you finish your sentence, wait a beat, and then say something that made the whole structure of what you'd just said collapse quietly from the inside.
One day he told me about Zeno. A Greek philosopher who argued you could never actually reach a destination — because to get there you first had to get halfway there, and before that halfway to the halfway, and so on, infinitely. Motion was an illusion. Nothing ever actually arrived anywhere.
I thought about it. It sounded airtight.
Butch looked at me and said that according to that logic, he couldn't reach out and touch me. He'd have to stop halfway. Then halfway again. He could never get there.
Then it dawned on me that he could smack me in the head any time he wanted.
He let that sit for a moment.
The argument was perfect, he said. And it was completely wrong. And the reason it was wrong was that someone else had built it, and I had walked into it and started defending it without ever asking whether the foundation was sound. When you let someone else frame an argument, you're not arguing anymore. You're defending a position you never actually took. That is how people get controlled — not by force, not by law, but by the frames they accept without examining.
I have spent the better part of fifty-seven years trying to remember that.
He went on to become a nurse. When I told him I wanted to be a paramedic like him, he said: be a nurse. You can do more for your patients. Paramedics rescue people from the current crisis. Nurses get the time after — to teach, to guide, to help someone understand what happened and what might prevent the next one.
He was right. He usually was.
I'll be sixty-nine this year. Butch and I are still in touch. When someone teaches you at twelve how to question the frame, you tend to keep going back to them when the frames get complicated.
The box isn't real. The only limits that actually hold are the physical laws of the universe. Everything else is something someone built — and something someone built can be examined, questioned, and if necessary, walked right through.
That was the first thing I learned outside my own house. It is still the most useful.
Comments